Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief + Snap + Eternal Witness + Simic Growth Chamber + Gift of Paradise

5-card combo · GU

Verdict

Yes — this 5-card loop generates infinite colored mana and ETB triggers in any Simic shell that can assemble lands, a bounce spell, and a recursion engine.

Cards required
5
Cheapest stack total
$7.17
Color identity
GU
Popularity
6 decks
Format
Commander
Buy required cards on TCGplayer

Simic Growth Chamber and a Gift of Paradise host land together produce enough mana to cast Snap, bounce Eternal Witness, and replay everything each cycle; Ivy copies Snap to untap the lands a second time per loop, netting mana with each iteration. The result is infinite storm count, infinite magecraft triggers, and infinite ETB and LTB events off Eternal Witness and Ivy themselves. Ivy, Gleeful Spellthief commanders or Simic spell-copy shells are the natural home, since Ivy needs to be in the command zone or otherwise consistently in play to close the loop.

Recipe

How it works

01

Prerequisites

02

Steps

  1. Activate Simic Growth Chamber and the land with Gift of Paradise attached by tapping them, adding {1}{G}{G}{U}.
  2. Cast Snap by paying {1}{U}, targeting Eternal Witness.
  3. Ivy triggers, copying Snap, targeting Ivy.
  4. Resolve the copy of Snap, returning Ivy from the battlefield to your hand and untapping Simic Growth Chamber and the land with Gift of Paradise attached.
  5. Activate Simic Growth Chamber and the land with Gift of Paradise attached by tapping them, adding {2}{G}{U}.
  6. Resolve Snap, returning Eternal Witness from the battlefield to your hand and untapping Simic Growth Chamber and the land with Gift of Paradise attached.
  7. Cast Ivy by paying {G}{U}.
  8. Cast Eternal Witness by paying {1}{G}{G}.
  9. Eternal Witness enters the battlefield, returning Snap from your graveyard to your hand.
  10. Repeat.

03

Result

Infinite colored mana; Infinite ETB; Infinite LTB; Infinite magecraft triggers; Infinite storm count; Infinite mana lands you control can produce; Infinite untap of lands you control

Variations

Cheaper, tighter, alternate lines

The combo is tight on substitutions — Gift of Paradise is load-bearing as the mana enchantment on the bounce-back land, and Snap is the only 2-mana bounce that untaps two lands as part of the cost. Once mana goes infinite, outlet options are wide open: Thassa's Oracle empties the library immediately, and Walking Ballista converts the mana into a table kill.

Verified on Commander Spellbook · Combo ID eternal-witness-simic-growth-chamber-snap

← All combos

Updated . Data from Commander Spellbook, Scryfall, and EDHREC.